Reading to children is not enough!

“If every parent, or carer …read aloud a minimum of three stories a day to children in their care, we could eliminate illiteracy within one generation.”

This is one of Mem Fox’s favourite bylines. Every time she is interviewed she likes to declare how she is going to solve illiteracy. Unfortunately she is wrong!

The first time I saw this quote was on a poster in our school library. My daughter had just been diagnosed with Dyslexia. I was already filled with enough parental guilt for not intervening in her schooling earlier. I really didn’t at that point to need any more guilt. It made me so sad and so angry. For a few years I had been asking teachers questions. They would answer …”she seems so bright!” “We don’t know why!” “Don’t worry she will get it.” “Do you read to her?”

Now I know better. I know I did do all the right things to give my daughter the best chance to read. But my daughter has Dyslexia and she did not receive the instruction she needed in school to teach her to read. I know that reading to your child is foundational to learning to read. But I also know that for most children it is not enough and they need to be taught explicitly how to read.

Yes I did read to my daughter more than any parent I know. She was my first child. I left my job as a teacher and spent all my energy playing with my child, talking to my child, singing to my child and reading to her.

From the moment she was born we read to her. We knew her favourite books off by heart. I remember her screaming in the car once so from the front I recited the entire “Each Peach Pear Plum” which was a definite favourite. Books were always how we settled her before every sleep, calmed her when upset and comforted when she was ill.

I remember being part of a government survey when she was a toddler and one question asked whether I read to my daughter 10 minutes a day. I laughed. The lady must have thought I was crazy as I was thinking it was more like hours. It was the thing she wanted to do most. Even before she could walk she would crawl over and grab books out of her book box for us to read. She never seemed to have enough.

I thought that once she learnt to walk she would not want to be read to so much. Instead she would toddle behind me demanding to be read to! One of her first sentences etched in my mind was “Read dis book yep!” All her grandparents, Aunties and Uncles read to her enthusiastically too. They include doctors, teachers a lawyer and even an author.

We owned about 6 or more Mem Fox books. I could recite to you “Time for bed” even now a decade after I read it to my child over and over every night before bed. My husband’s favourite was “Where is the green sheep?” He used to make up silly names for all the characters and would ask my daughter to point out the “Carmen Miranda sheep” and the “Ned Kelly sheep”.

Before school she spent 2 1/2 years at the local preschool. The year before school she had the most amazing preschool teacher 3 days a week who used to teach kindergarten. She read books to the children, did amazing activities, sang songs, played with rhymes.

So my daughter went to school primed to learn to read. She couldn’t have had a better foundation of oral language. In fact her preschool teachers commented about how good her vocabulary was. In her assessments later, when we were looking for answers, she was shown to have verbal comprehension and vocabulary well above average. She loved a complex story early.

In kindergarten we started reading her Harry Potter. Sometimes she’d be wriggling and I would accuse her of not listening. She would then recite to me the last line or tell me what the story line was for the last 10 minutes. At the same age her sister was still enjoying picture books being read to her.

So when she didn’t learn to read we were shocked. She so looked forward to learning to read books because she had always loved books so much. She struggled, she cried and threw predictive readers across the room. She began to hate and fear school. Eventually in year 3 we found out she had Dyslexia and at the age 8 1/2 she had a spelling age of less than 5 and a reading age of 7. After we employed a structured literacy tutor and she spent many hours with me at home reinforcing explicit phonics lessons she learnt to read. But that’s another story.

I know Mem Fox is a passionate advocate of whole language. A methodology of teaching that has been proven time and time again to be not an effective strategy to teach children to read. Her views are from a position of power but are based on significant ignorance. With power and influence comes a great responsibility because the myths you are spreading are doing damage. Kids are being left behind and families are being blamed for their children’s failure.

My understanding is not only supported by research evidence but by the thousands of parent stories I have heard in Dyslexia Support Australia. Parents over and over again tell how they were blamed for their child struggling to learn to read. They discuss in great detail how they always read to their child from day one, yet they did not learn to read. We have teachers in our support group who join when their own child struggles to learn to read. We have parents with multiple children but only one struggled.

I’m not discounting the importance of reading to children in the early development of oral language. It is an essential foundation for later reading acquisition. But well trained teachers can bridge the gap that some children bring to school with them. My child had no oral language gap. My child had no disadvantage other than a disability that could have been overcome without the heartbreak through early evidenced based intervention. Reading 3 books a day to children will not eradicate illiteracy. Training our teachers in systematic and explicit phonics instruction, phonemic awareness, vocabulary, fluency and comprehension will.

The cutie in the photos is my daughter being read to!

Advertisements

Published by

Dekker Delves into Dyslexia

Advocate for the introduction of the phonics check in Australia. Advocate for the teaching of evidence based literacy instruction for every child in every school. The explicit and systematic teaching of Phonemic Awareness, Phonics, Fluency, Vocabulary and Comprehension. Advocate for Dyslexia Awareness I support reputable organisations such as the Australian Dyslexia Association (ADA), Learning Difficulties Australia (LDA), the International Dyslexia Association (IDA), the FIVE from FIVE Project, and the International Foundation for Effective Reading Instruction (IFERI) AUSPELD and State-based SPELD organisations, as they all recommend the use of EVIDENCE-BASED TREATMENTS/PROGRAMS for learning difficulties. Mum to 2 delightful, amazing and creative kids. Mum to a kid with Dyslexia, Dysgraphia, Dyscalculia and anxiety. Admin of Dyslexia Support Australia Group, Dyslexia Awareness Australia and Dyscalculia Awareness Australia. Board of Directors SPELD NSW 10 Years a High School Teacher All my opinions are based not only on experience as a teacher, a mum and an administrator of Australia’s largest Dyslexia Support group but on research. I believe in the scientific method and the need for education to meet the same rigorous evidence based standards as the medical profession.

11 thoughts on “Reading to children is not enough!”

  1. Please read, ‘The Folly of Jolly Old Phonics’ on Mem Fox’s website if you want to understand how deeply Mem feels about systematic, structured, explicit phonics instruction.

    We need to comfort the afflicted, and afflict the comfortable. Mem is very comfortable with her views.

    Thank you Belinda for your honesty.

    Like

  2. Thank you Belinda for taking the time to set out you experience that so closely reflects others who have children with learning disabilities. My daughter has also been read to since she was in the womb and has a deep love of literature despite her dyslexia. I hope Membtakes note and joins as an advocate for early intervention.

    Like

  3. Sheer ignorance. It’s an insulting, outrageous type of a statement! Imagine if I stated that if parents didnt physically point out and identify objects to their children, it is the cause of so many children requiring glasses.
    A lack of being read to does not cause dyslexia, something a child is born with and genetic.

    Like

  4. Such a powerful message. I hope that Mem Fox actually reads this with an open mind and heart. The damage she and others like her are doing is immense. Their words hold significant power and they need to own that responsibility.

    Our story is much the same but went on for a lot longer. We did not get a diagnosis until the end of grade 5, even though I started asking about dyslexia in grade 1. I can’t count the amount of times I was told I just needed to read to her more and she just needed to try harder. The damage done to my daughter’s mental health is unforgivable. It is because of people like Mem Fox spouting their ill informed nonsense that I struggled to find the answers for my girl. It is a minefield of misinformation out there, this delays finding the correct information.

    Like

  5. Thank you so much Belinda! Your story is so similar to my own and Mem Fox needs to stop blaming us for the literacy disaster we are seeing in schools!! Our house is filled with books and I have read avidly to all my children since the day they were born. My eldest child appeared to learn to read by osmosis!! How lucky he was. My 2nd child was so excited to start school because all he wanted to do was to learn to read by himself!! A bright little boy, he used to immerse himself in documentaries to learn everything he could about animals (reptiles a clear favourite!!). We would read book after book to him, with bedtime fights because he wanted more books! But along with school came the onset of his mental health problems, when my intelligent and enthusiastic little boy couldn’t understand why he wasn’t able to learn to read. He tried so hard!!!! He ‘read’ all the predictive texts that came home (he just memorised them and guessed the other bits!), we worked for hours on learning the magic high fluency words but he was unable to remember them. We continued to read book after book to him. While all along his teachers kept telling me it would all fall into place because he was bright. But to no avail … At the end of grade 1 when my child still couldn’t read and didn’t know the sounds the letters made I took things into my own hands and began researching; eventually he was diagnosed with dyslexia. But so much damage had already been done. My happy little boy was having panic attacks at the age of 7!! Terrified of going to school because it was too hard and everyone would think he was dumb. With the help of some amazing people (namely his paediatrician, psychologist, and our amazing MSL tutor), my boy at grade 5 is now reading independently and at level!! (Insert happy dance!) With a synthetic and explicit phonics approach the results were amazing! Unfortunately for my son, the anxiety remains … and the struggle continues. It has been an expensive journey for our family as we self-fund for everything he needs because School cannot provide it. And my third child? Well he has dyslexia too (with ADHD thrown in on the side!). Mem Fox, please don’t ignore the research and please stop blaming us parents for the low literacy rates of Australia. You have a privileged position but unfortunately it is an ill-informed one that I feel may be doing more harm than good …

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Thank you again Belinda for your fabulous advocacy. My story is very similar to yours. I am was an early years teacher who loved children’s literature so much I went on to become a teacher-librarian. I read to my children when they were in the womb and read and read and read to them almost ever fabulous book in our local library. Mem needs to know our stories too. 💕

    Like

  7. I really hope Mem Fox takes heed of your powerful story Belinda. People in positions of influence, such as Mem Fox, should be especially careful not to spruik such ill-informed nonsense.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s